American Idol Update

So Carly Smithson got eliminated tonight. I thought she was a really good singer, but I don't know if she deserved to go tonight or not. I don't think she was going to win, and she wasn't my favorite by far...It was interesting to say the least. Oh well, when you get to the point when there are this few people left in the competition they're all generally going to be good singers. It's just a question as to whether or not they have the other factors like personality, etc.